29
Aug
2010
and now’s the time the time is now…
By Jae. Posted in everyone's a critic | 4 Comments »›
hammer of the gods will drive our ships to new lands…
for my second installment of taking a band and listening to and dissecting their discography to come up with a top 20 list i went with zeppelin. what i think i’ve discovered through this process is that i’m not as big of a zeppelin fan as i once thought i was or at least once thought i was supposed to be. not that i’m not a fan, i am… but this process was pretty painless and easy because i was able to quickly eliminate many songs. i’m not really that into blues, which of course zep takes a huge influence from. i also am not a big fan of robert plant’s vocal or lyrical talents. not to say he isn’t talented, just not my favorite cup of tea. i do think that john paul jones is the unsung hero of the band and doesn’t typically get the credit he deserves for his role in what many might argue was one of the greatest bands ever.
20. Carouselambra
In Through the Out Door
it’s really hard for me to hear synthesizer and not jump instantly to 80’s cheese… and more often than not i am not gonna like it, but this synth-fest transcends that for me and it works. this song doesn’t feel like the over 10 minute length it is because it takes you for a ride and changes it up along the way. not necessarily a bad thing, but plant is at perhaps his most indiscernible, i don’t think i actually know a single lyric… except the ahh-ahhhs… which i like.
19. What is and What Shall Never Be
Led Zeppelin II
i like the mellow, sing-songy verses followed up with the catchy, heavier chorus. plant’s mystical vibe with the lyrics, against the sounds of the guitar washing from your left ear… through your brain and to the right… like waves, is kind of a dreamy experience.
18. Hey Hey What Can I do
Led Zeppelin III
(not on album, but released as b-side to immigrant song)
love the acoustic with the mandolin overlay… gives it a really pleasant, mellow vibe. i’ve mentioned that robert plant is not a favorite singer of mine, but i do like his vocals here.
17. Dancing Days
Houses of the Holy
if there’s one thing zeppelin knows how to do it’s how to establish a riff that engrains in your brain. this is another example. you can’t listen and not want to move.
16. Trampled Under Foot
Physical Graffiti
that riff is relentless and impossible not to groove to. jpj rocks the keyboards. i think the lyrics are kinda silly… a bit too heavy-handed on the car/sex metaphor for my taste, but fortunately i normally can’t tell what the hell plant is saying anyway, so it’s not that big an issue.
15. Houses of the Holy
Physical Graffiti
one of their catchiest, it works all the way around. one of my favorite things about this song is how the last line of each verse seems to add a little bit more and kinda keeps building. taking a rather simple lyrical 4 line structure and adding a lot of interest.
14. Poor Tom
Coda
kind of a different little song… a more folksy story ballad sung behind bonham’s prominent and driving drums.
13. Bron-Y-Aur Stomp
Led Zeppelin III
with fantastic acoustic playing from page and the foot-stomping percussion antics provided by bonham… i have no idea why this song isn’t more popular.
12. Over the Hills and Far Away
Houses of the Holy
i love the acoustic beginning… i love the beautiful, wistful ending… and the middle is a cool, harder diversion that separates the two.
11. Misty Mountain Hop
(Untitled) (Led Zeppelin IV) etc.
i actually think plant is the star on this one. i really like the vocal harmonies. i like the phrasing and i also like the whole hippie, high, love-in retro vibe the lyrics give off. a perfect fit for him. this is a song that evokes a specific time and aura that i feel a part of, despite never having been there.
10. Fool in the Rain
In Through the Out Door
this song to me has a lot going on…in a good way because i feel like i could hear it another hundred times and still hear new things. there are parts where i can’t determine what exactly is making what sound in my ears.
what i can distinguish are the drums… which i love in this song. and of course, the whistle… which ushers in the part that always has and always will remind me of “peanuts” (as in schroeder, not the food or the packing materials)
9. That’s the Way
Led Zeppelin III
the guitar work is gorgeous. i love how it feels like it’s flowing along sweetly and then builds up into the chorus that has a haunting feel to it.
8. Stairway to Heaven
(Untitled) (Led Zeppelin IV) etc.
it’s really kind of impossible to effectively rank this song objectively due to the over saturation of it. it would be generous to say i’d be fine hearing it maybe once a decade. i do still think it’s a great song, but i don’t believe it to be their best… i think ultimately, number 8 is a fair place to put it.
7. When the Levee Breaks
(Untitled) (Led Zeppelin IV) etc.
here’s a song that back in the day, when i first listened to the album, i didn’t dislike, but never really liked either… it was just there sort of. but in re-listening to it for this project it floored me. sludgy and heavy… kind of a grungy feel, and of course, the drums. just…wow.
6. The Rain Song
Houses of the Holy
in addition to being a beautiful song and lyrically one of their best (with that perfect last line) this one also has significant sentimental value. our first xmas, mr. j and i were still living in different states and saving money for his relocation, so we decided to only give presents that didn’t cost anything. he sent me a recording of him doing this song. one of the best presents i’ve ever gotten.
5. The Song Remains the Same
Houses of the Holy
i think this one being this high on the list is a bit surprising… i wouldn’t have called it before this exercise. but it feels very layered and textured and it twists and turns and changes itself up… and nice bass too.
i get a dream theater-ish vibe from it… and not just because they covered it in their zep medley on “change of seasons”. of course i’ve been told by a huge zeppelin fan (mr. j) and a huge dream theater fan (son, branden) that i’m crazy…
4. Going to California
(Untitled) (Led Zeppelin IV) etc.
the most beautiful of their softer, acoustic stuff… what’s not to like here. with an understated and simple feel… dreamy mandolin and something about how plant inhales at the beginning that immediately puts you in the right headspace to drift along in the music…
3. Achilles Last Stand
Presence
this is truly an epic song. i purposely have refrained from talking too much about bonham’s drumming… because i wanted to make sure i didn’t get too redundant when i got to this point. i don’t know how to articulate it in a profound way… but he just absolutely rocks. then you have that dukkita, dukkita driving bass line. and then the end which brings us back full circle to the beginning. yeah, epic.
2. Kashmir
Physical Graffiti
technically, i think this is their most perfect song. hypnotic, dramatic, brooding, atmospheric, sexy, transcendental. (ok, i’m not positive i know what that exactly means… lol… but it sounds right) the point is… it’s grand and everybody individually doing what they do best, cohesively as a single unit.
what it comes down to is when i think led zeppelin, this is what comes to mind… to me, this song defines them.
1. Ten Years Gone
Physical Graffiti
yeah, how do i possibly top #2… well, really… i don’t. if i’m being completely honest, i think zeppelin’s best song is my number 2… however, this one tops the list for me personally because it’s the total package… love the lyrics… love the music… i love how the lyrics fit and compliment the music perfectly. ultimately, this song is the one zeppelin song that has the strongest emotional resonance… and making us feel something… that’s what music is all about.
if the rain song has the best closing line, this one has the best opening line.
then as it was, then again it will be.
just for fun… this was mr. j’s list
20 The Wanton Song
19 Poor Tom
18 What is and What Should Never Be
17 The Crunge
16 That’s The Way
15 Misty Mountain Hop
14 Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp
13 Custard Pie
12 When the Levee Breaks
11 No Quarter
10 Whole Lotta Love
9 Ramble On
8 Four Sticks
7 Tea For One
6 Stairway to Heaven
5 Immigrant Song
4 Trampled Underfoot
3 Kashmir
2 Achilles Last Stand
1 Black Dog
and now it gets difficult… i’ve already begun the next band in this life-long project and it is one of my absolute favorites… right now i can’t possibly fathom how on earth i’m going to compile my list. just when i think i’ve got a song figured out… i change my mind.
4 Comments »













